Outside of the five matches listed above, the rest of Styles’ WrestleMania resume isn’t remembered very fondly. Most fans will point to his matchup with Shinsuke Nakamura at WrestleMania 34, which many hoped would be similar to their classic at NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 10, but instead were witness to an underwhelming 20-minute contest. To make matters worse, WrestleMania 34 should’ve seen Nakamura crowned as WWE Champion after winning the Royal Rumble that year, but the company chose to have him fall short and turn heel instead. The clash between Styles and Nakamura in 2018 could possibly be one of the most disappointing WrestleMania matches of all-time.

The three other WrestleMania matches to Styles’ name are not necessarily poor efforts, but just standard contests that are often forgotten about. His singles matches with Logan Paul and Randy Orton initially seemed like sleeper picks to steal the show, but unfortunately neither battle was much different from the wrestling on WWE’s weekly television. Additionally, Styles’ WWE Tag Team Championship win alongside Omos against The New Day felt like a filler match on a strong WrestleMania 37 night one card.